I have had both of those brands, but in terms of the Haagen Das pints of ice cream I haven't had one in years. I usually just eat the bars they have. Those are very good by the way. I rarely eat Ben and jerry's for one thing, it is quite expensive, and for another, it has about twice the calories of normal ice cream. So, I guess I might go for Haagen Das. They used to have an flavor called Cassis i really liked, and their Rum Raisin was really intense and good.