Yes, but you are still stealing. Because you see there are these funny little warning about illegal copying of either cds or movies. It doesn't matter if someone bought it, afterall someone originally bought the music someone is currently downloading offline. Someone originally paid to go to the movie they videotaped and are now selling on the corner. Someone paid for the membership that allows them to make pirated copies of music and movie - so why is their way wrong and your way right? It isn't, but because no money is being exchanged you feel better about it. In the way of downloading no money is being exchanged and therefore (by your reasoning) nothing wrong is occuring. Perfect.