Would you like a used engagement ring? I was on eBay and saw a bunch. Personally I'd want a new one even if it were much more modest (you can save a lot buying used jewelry IF you know what you are doing). Would it bother you if your engagement ring came from someone else's broken engagement? I'm not taking about a family heirloom that is being passed down from generation to generation here. I'm talking specifically something that comes from Ebay, the pawn shop, Craigslist, etc.